In Black Swan how much seduction is real?
In the film Black Swan there are a number of scenes where Nina and Thomas Leroy have a more than professional relationship. Are these real or are they part of her illness (in the same way as parts of her relationship with Lily).
There are three sections I can think of:
- The kiss which gets her the part
- The scene in the studio
- The kiss during the performance
Do we have any evidence that any of these didn't happen?
ETA: The scene in the studio I mentioned earlier was where Thomas Leroy pretended to seduce her to get her to give the performance.
Best Answer
The kiss that gets her the part has to be real. Otherwise, how does she get the part? Furthermore, Thomas says that "he saw a bit of that earlier" in reference to it.
By the scene in the studio, you mean where Thomas is having sex with Lily, right? Because that's Nina's imagination. She's paranoid that Lily is using sex to get ahead of her, and when the whole set becomes all black, the music and mise-en-scene imply that her paranoia is starting to take over.
The kiss during the performance is real. It's a part of her "performance" as a Black Swan, so the only way the kiss couldn't be real is if her entire performance was her imagination.
I think Black Swan is open to a lot of interpretations, but these are the answers that make the most sense to me.
Pictures about "In Black Swan how much seduction is real?"
Is Nina a virgin in Black Swan?
No coincidence Nina is a sexual Virgin. So this is the story of Nina's journey to sexual awakening against her mother's wishes. It is in the same category as The Virgin Suicides.Is Black Swan explicit?
BLACK SWAN is an extremely unpleasant movie, packed with some of the most bizarrely unhinged and immoral behavior to be seen on the big screen in ages. Included are some graphic sexual content, explicit lesbianism and extreme violence.Is Black Swan feminist?
Black Swan is winning awards and stirring up discussion left and right. The film engages a number of feminist themes in the story of Nina, a ballet dancer obsessed with achieving perfection.What actually happens in Black Swan?
As Nina succinctly describes the ballet, "It's about a girl who gets turned into a swan, and she needs love to break the spell, but her prince falls for the wrong girl so she kills herself." The characters in Black Swan are even credited with two names, the second corresponding to their role in Swan Lake.a swan is born - black swan scene
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Pixabay, Petr Ganaj, Daniel Frank, KoolShooters