Who slashed Matt Reynold's throat in LA Confidential?

In LA confidential, Sid Hudgens and Jack Vincennes set up this one kid, Matt Reynolds, to have sex with the district attorney so they can take pictures of the two of them. However, when Jack has a change of heart and shows up at the motel to stop Matt, Matt is found with his throat slashed.

Did the District Attorney panic and do it?
Did Sid set the whole thing up to kill Matt?
Did Sid and his associates kill Matt after they had the pictures to prevent any leaks?
Or was it just a random murder?

plot-explanation la-confidential

Best Answer

First of all, Sid worked for Cpt. Dudley Smith and this setup was actually done for him, in order to give his dark schemes some backing from DA Loew. The dialogue during Bud's and Exley's "interrogation" of the DA makes this clear, and it also gives the reason why Matt ultimately had to die:

Loew: Dudley Smith is a highly decorated officer of this city's police department. I won't smear his and Pierce Patchett's name without...

Exley: Without what, them smearing yours first? What do they have on you, Loew? Pictures of you and an out of work actor with your pants down?

...

Loew: Okay! Okay! Pierce Patchett and Dudley! I wouldn't play ball so they hatched this blackmail scheme to destroy me. I capitulated. The kid heard everything so they killed him.

So Matt had to die because he overheard the argument between the DA and Dudley/Patchett and from then on knew too much (similar to the third theory from the question). Who it was then? Most probably one of Dudley's henchmen, or maybe even Dudley himself, given that he doesn't seem to have any problems with making his own hands dirty.