Why does William Stryker say he gave Wolverine claws even though he had them way before?

Why does William Stryker say he gave Wolverine claws even though he had them way before? - Drone view of light beige sandy beach of vibrant green wavy ocean next to cottage surrounded by grass and palms

In X2, just right before Wolverine chains Stryker to the chopper, William Stryker says the following:

People don't change, Wolverine.

You were an animal then. You're an animal now.

I just gave you claws.

But Wolverine, even though they weren't that shiny, had claws ever since. Why does Stryker claim that he gave him claws.



Best Answer

This is a perfectly acceptable communication if he is only speaking figuratively. "Claws" doesn't mean only physical, literal claws, it is a metaphor for the ability to be violent, to be competently violent. He might very well have said the same thing if he had armed him with a rifle.

And, if we examine these movies closely, Wolverine becomes physically capable of even more extreme violence. Before he merely regenerated, now he can tear open a metal vault to get to you. Before, you could cripple him for minutes by breaking his bones, now they simply do not break and he does not slow down.

The "claws" metaphor is fairly widespread. He would have used the word "claws" even if Wolverine instead had a stinger, or fangs, or horns.




Pictures about "Why does William Stryker say he gave Wolverine claws even though he had them way before?"

Why does William Stryker say he gave Wolverine claws even though he had them way before? - Low angle of road sign with Route 66 End of the Trail inscription located near fast food restaurant against cloudy evening sky on Santa Monica Beach
Why does William Stryker say he gave Wolverine claws even though he had them way before? - Grey Empty Road Between fields
Why does William Stryker say he gave Wolverine claws even though he had them way before? - Old trolleybus driving along wet asphalt road in small city at foggy night



How did Wolverine originally get his claws?

Despite the movies being completely wrong about the adamantium process, wolverine did get the claws due to the process but it wasn't injected into him. He had bands of adamantium strapped to his body and they were super heated till they burned through his skin and laced his bones.

Why did Stryker put adamantium in Wolverine?

Bad guy Colonel William Stryker originally coated Wolverine's skeleton in the material because the mutant already possessed a knack for healing, meaning he could recover from injuries and surgeries without dying. He planned on using Wolverine as a weapon, but Wolverine escaped.

Did Wolverine have claws originally?

14 THE CLAWS ARE PART OF HIS SKELETON The other writers liked the idea (to David's surprise) and they had Magneto pull out the adamantium through Wolverine's pores. They did not want him to not have claws, still, though, so they revealed in Wolverine #75 that he was actually born with claws! He just didn't remember it.

How did Wolverine get his claws back after they were cut off?

During the final fight in The Wolverine, Logan-San had his adamantium claws sliced clean off by The Silver Samurai, leaving him with organic bone claws that grow back through the stubs of the adamantium coating.



Wolverine Refuses To Rejoin Stryker Scene | X-Men Origins Wolverine (2009) Movie Clip HD 4K




More answers regarding why does William Stryker say he gave Wolverine claws even though he had them way before?

Answer 2

The X-Men films typically follow mainstream knowledge of the comics. Wolverine wasn't known to have bone claws by the general audience, so they didn't mention it. The Bone Claws reveal was only done in 1993, recent compared to Wolverines entire history. He's typically depicted as thinking that he gained claws from the Weapon X program.

Wolverine has always had memory issues. He normally doesn't know who he really is, or his childhood. Readers didn't find out he was James Howlet until the Wolverine Origin comic in 2002, which was then used as the basis for the Movie. That revealed that Wolverine always had bone claws as far back as childhood, and Sabertooth was his blood brother.

X2 was released in 2003, so incorporating anything from 2002 into the script would have been unlikely.

Notice that Wolverine is confused in Days of Future Past, when he wakes up the 60s and has bone claws instead of metal. His memory was erased at the end of Origin by an Adamantium bullet to the brain, courtesy of Striker. Xavier is shown to be working to help Wolverine regain his memory through out all the movies.

Assuming all of this is in continuity, Stryker has been shown to be quite smart, cunning and willing to use people, and having known Wolverine suffered memory loss, his wording can be assumed to be an intentional omission. He admits what Wolverine already knows, and doesn't volunteer what he doesn't.

Answer 3

The X-Men film series has an ever-shifting canon. With the first two films, it is established that a number of handheld adamantium guns were used over an extended period of time to graft the metal to Logan's skeleton. With X-Men Origins: Wolverine, however, the scene was changed to show a number of automated rods simply impaling Logan's body and covering his skeleton, including the claws, in adamantium.

With X2, it can be inferred that Logan did not have the claws already, so this was by Stryker's doing. With X-Men Origins: Wolverine, however, the procedure was done to make Logan formidable enough that he could successfully combat Victor. So, if we were to smooth over this continuity discrepancy, Stryker's line in X2 simply means that he gave Logan the proper means to match his natural ferocity.

Answer 4

You didn't have to take that dialogue that literally. He doesn't mean that he didn't have claws before, but he means that he didn't have the Adamantium claw before.

So he means that he was an animal way before that experiment and he just gave a weapon to an animal.

Answer 5

Wolverine didn´t have claws back then!

His mutant powers were self healing, and heightened smell.That was a retcon done by Marvel close to the Wolverine movies in the 2000s

Here a link:

http://www.thegeektwins.com/2009/05/i-hate-wolverines-bone-claws-too.html#.WVW5qus1-Uk

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Pok Rie, Enric Cruz López, Peter Fazekas, Тамара Левченко