Did Miles Dyson kill all these policemen?
I stumbled upon this recent question about Terminator 2, in particular about the scene where Miles Dyson dies after having been wounded lethally and trying to buy time for the others by detonating a grenade. He warns the upcoming SWAT team that the grenade will go off shortly and they run away.
This question states that the policemen didn't have enough time to escape the explosion. But I for myself always thought they made it out of the explosion radius in time, but then again, I'm not totally sure about this anymore, since this question says they surely didn't have enough time as judged by the immediate cut to the explosion destroying the building (although I vaguely remember it to only destroy a single floor).
The reason I'm asking this is, that I think the fact of the policemen dying would bring a major inconsistency with the general moral justification of the heroes' actions throughout the movie. There are actually no real human enemies in this movie and the movie more than one time elaborates on the fact, that the heroes (and especially the supposedly good Terminator) don't kill anyone, in order for the viewer to better identify with them on a moral basis. Whereas the previous movie had that touch of sweet immorality, once you decided that it is cool to watch Arnie run around and kill everybody, this one goes to great lengths to show him as a "good guy", especially in the scene more or less immediately before the questioned one. And in the end most action movies where the hero kills multiple bad guys in a row still try not to show him directly killing innocents.
So I see different possibilities for this:
- The SWAT team didn't die and managed to escape in time.
- Their death is to be justified as kind of collateral damage (in line with all the others killed by the T-1000, the "evil Terminator"), since Dyson didn't kill them completely on purpose.
- Their death is merely ignored or justified with a sense of "the end justifies the means" (which IMHO wouldn't be in line with the movie's previous moral elaborations, though).
- It is left open for the viewer to decide (which in turn was a bit too "heavy" an aspect for such a straight-to-the-point action movie).
And my question is, did the SWAT team die from Miles Dyson's grenade, and if yes, how is this supposed to be justified?
(disclaimer: Now it might be that this has been intentionally left open for interpretation which would make this a bit of an open discussion question. But I might also just have overlooked something (or not remebering it that well) or there is even an official statement about this from the writers.)
Best Answer
I stumbled upon this recent question about Terminator 2, in particular about the scene where Miles Dyson dies after having been wounded lethally and trying to buy time for the others by detonating a grenade. He warns the upcoming SWAT team that the grenade will go off shortly and they run away.
You are implying in the question that there was a moral line the film didn't want to cross. Where no humans are intentionally killed.
Except, Sarah goes to Dyson's home and shoots him in front of his wife and kid. Attempted murder is just as morally wrong as murder. The terminator then cuts the flesh off his arm to show he's a machine. So violence wasn't some hidden in the film.
I don't think the moral line is drawn in the sand as deeply as you imply, and the film was Rated R so there wasn't an issue with violence.
Still, the question isn't the morality, but if the police survived the explosions.
Here are a couple of facts, because I happen to be watching it on Netflix when this question came up.
- The police enter the science lab from the stairwell, and that is the same door they leave in when they run out.
- I was able to count to about 14 seconds from the time the police start moving before the bomb goes off.
- Sarah, Arnold and the kid are in the elevator when the bomb goes off, and have no problem surviving the explosion.
- The bomb doesn't destroy the floor. It only destroys the research lab on that floor (see image below). The fireball only comes out from a wide second, but clearly not the entire floor.
- When Arnold exists the elevator the same SWAT team is there waiting for them. They were able to get downstairs before the elevator. I was find the same actor playing a SWAT team member both before and after the bomb explosion (see image below).
Explosion Of Research Lab
SWAT Team Member Before/After Explosion
So it's clear the SWAT team didn't die, and they actually appear again in the next scene. Sadly they are all shot in the leg by Arnold. Black guy with big explosive bomb zero points. Terminator with hand gun 10 points. You have to feel sorry to Dyson. First Sarah shoots him, then the swat team shoots him and then he blows up.
I'm going to watch the rest of the film. If I see anything else that I can add, then I'll be back.
Pictures about "Did Miles Dyson kill all these policemen?"
T2: Miles Dyson Assassination Attempt Comparison
More answers regarding did Miles Dyson kill all these policemen?
Answer 2
I always assumed SWAT didn't die -- that Dyson was able to hold the detonator long enough for SWAT to get to safety.
If it's true that the scene-cutting didn't allow enough time elapse for the SWAT escape, I have to think this was an editing decision made for visual effect -- not to indicate that the SWAT guys were killed.
Killing SWAT would not add value to the story, but killing SWAT would add conflict with rest of the movie's "don't-kill-innocent-cops" theme.
Answer 3
When the Terminator goes out into the parking lot and teargasses the cops he drives a Police truck back into the Cyberdyne building. As he does so the cops can be seen in the foyer trying to get to the front doors to leave, they scatter as the truck comes through the doors. Hope this ties it up.
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Brett Sayles, Elijah O'Donnell, Antony Trivet, Mike B